Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kurt's avatar

That's pretty good. I especially like seeing Noah enter a sputtering stage wherein he's made to look the fool he is. The only thing I'd add is the elephant in the room; no one's talking about it. It's so big, it fills the room; there's no room left to talk. To whit...

The incompatibility of liberal democracy with large populations in incredibly complex societies. It's not like no one's noticed it before...Aristotle, James Madison, Alexander Fraser Tytler, Lippmann...they all had on point observations about the inability of US type liberal democracy to handle things. It's not that I don't like the idea of it; I love the idea. But, it doesn't scale.

Mencken described democracy as "a pathetic belief in the collective wisdom of individual ignorance." There've been various examples of this throughout history, but the current situation in the US of A is putting it in stark relief. Compound it with the inherent problem of media conglomerates that have moved beyond the 4th Estate to arbiters of everything, making public service so miserable for anyone in office that only sociopaths find it attractive. Add the internet, designed to accelerate extremist engagement, and it sure seems like we've achieved critical mass for a meltdown. I'm not worried, but I've been in survival mode for the last 50 years. It seemed prudent.

Which is not to say I'm predicting disaster; only fools make predictions. But, the show's just starting. Pass the popcorn.

Expand full comment

No posts

Ready for more?