Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alexandria's avatar

I agree with your assessment about 'Breakneck' wholeheartedly. I tried reading it a few weeks ago; couldn't finish. I did, however, listen a few interviews that Wang's given.

In Silicon Valley, where I work, the anxiety and tension are especially palpable ever since DeepSeek and more recently, intensified by OpenAI hacking into HuggingFace / debate between open-weight vs. closed models. The popularity of the book is certainly benefiting from this macro / micro context instead of on its own merit.

I am also not surprised zero so-called 'international communication' professionals had heard about the book. My observation about the Chinese media is that they mostly served the purpose of 'selling' the narrative under certain direct/indirect 'guidance'; single, rather than bilateral.

Both US and China are 'talking at' each other, but neither of them listen. So much about 'communication' - it takes two to dance.

It trickled into dinner table conversation too, creating some 'interesting moments' between friends/family who came from either sides. I would like to see evidence first-hand and make my own judgement. The autumn tour is very timely. Thanks for organizing. When I will clear my Oct schedule, I shall apply.

P A M Verhagen's avatar

Breakneck isn't worth reading, and it's a good thing that Chinese people are not aware of it. It will spare them much aggravation.

The book is a sustained, laboriously writtten ideological attack on China disguised as a memoire of the author's few years back in the country of his birth. It fills dozens of pages with irrelevant sorties into China's past, including the COVID years, tacks on an equally irrelevant autobiographical chapter, and ticks all the boxes of current US prejudice.

No posts

Ready for more?